Sandwiches, Burgers,  Wraps & More 
Something for everyone!

About Fireside Cafe


Mixed greens with a variety of toppings and dressings.

Our Specialties


Locally roasted coffee, specialty beverages, Pepsi fountain drinks, and more

It's not every day you have the opportunity to turn a hobby into your career.  With the help of their families, husband and wife team Marsha and Corey returned to his hometown of Shipshewana to do exactly that. 
Marsha and Corey met in college while pursuing degrees in the computer field. Upon graduation, they both spent time working in their field of study, but neither were truly happy with where their degrees had taken them.
Then, the opportunity came along to leave their careers behind and follow their dream of opening a restaurant.  Life often takes strange twists and turns.  Thanks to many of those twists and turns, lots of help from family and friends, and a huge leap of faith, we proudly bring you Fireside Cafe.

The people behind it...

Platters & Entrees

Hearty portions of Fireside specialties

Fireside Cafe is a restaurant featuring house-smoked meats, homemade recipes, super-premium ice cream, locally roasted coffee, and more.

Visit us in our beautiful, cozy dining room or in Shipshewana's first drive-thru, which is car, buggy, bicycle, and tractor-friendly!  You will find us located in Yoder's Shopping Center in Shipshewana.